DavidNissenKahn
Member since September 2026
Should U.S. presidential candidates be required to pass a cognitive test to appear on the ballot?
Should hospitals stop providing gender-affirming care to transgender minors?
As per JE_Thomas: In principle, hospitals (and other healthcare facilities including medical offices) should provide evidence-based state-of-the-art care to all comers. The caveat is evidence-based care. Several commentators have pointed out that the evidence for aggressive gender affirming care for minors, as opposed to supportive care, is fraught with uncertainties and unclarities (my word). I'm an adult internist, not a pediatrician, so I'm unable to comment with meaning. Given that the FDA/NIH/CDC et alias are rapidly abdicating their positions as aloof arbiters, we'll have to depend on (obviously uninvolved, disinterested, impartial) committees of qualified pediatricians, endocrinologists, psychiatrists/psychologists to evolve recommendations. I tend to side with dagman: Irreversible is pretty much just what it says.
Yeah, o' course. For the nonce, 'til evidence (see how I roped that in) shows otherwise, I'm inclined to trust the major pediatric and psychiatric organizations. Nothing else to go by, is there?
Scaramouche is right. Too many questions about administration and interpretation.