dagmanVoice #1
Member since July 2026
Should the U.S. fund a high-speed rail network?
Is JetBlue right to raise its checked-bag fees again?
Silly question. Can't imagine anyone would vote yes here.
Should the 2026 midterm results be treated as a verdict on President Trump?
Absolutely. Already feels like a weight has been lifted. I suspect much of the world feels the same. Would be ironic if our response to Trump-inspired division brought us a bit closer together. Probably wishful thinking, but one can hope.
Would you be willing to bank with a tech company instead of a traditional bank?
Depends. If an Apple, Google, or Microsoft, maybe. They'd also need the same FDIC protections as the major banks. I want significant capital and an established brand behind my bank.
Is it acceptable for President Trump to tie federal disaster aid to Republican election wins?
For a guy obsessed with election fraud, he's remarkably comfortable abusing his power to influence election outcomes. Let's hope it backfires on Nov 3.
Agree that both are bad. At least under the FEMA case, the individual responsible was fired: https://abc7.com/post/fema-employee-removed-role-after-telling-team-skip-houses-trump-signs-post-hurricane-milton-florida/15530823/ I don't see this as a partisan issue, but rather a Trump issue.
Should AI chatbots add a hidden watermark to the text they generate?
I'm sure tools to remove those watermarks will follow shortly, but it's worth a shot. My guess is that it'll remain hard to detect AI generated content with any certainty.
Should cars keep physical buttons for basic controls instead of touchscreens?
Touchscreens in cars have gone a bit too far, I think. Great for display, not for control. I prefer being able to control most functions without taking my eyes off the road.
Should President Trump be allowed to build a triumphal arch in Washington, D.C.?
I'd likely feel differently about it under any other president. No more vanity projects.
Was Democratic Rep. Haley Stevens right to endorse Republican Mike Rogers in Michigan's Senate race?
Feel like she put her personal differences ahead of the party in a very important election. Don't think it'll matter much in the end, but bad for both her political career and the party.
Have you been scammed online?
Scamming is getting more sophisticated by the day with AI. We're going to have to be hypervigilant / borderline paranoid to avoid scams in the future.
Was Apple right to use Alibaba's Qwen AI to power Apple Intelligence in China?
Don't think they had much choice if they want to sell iPhones in China.
Should the U.S. back new elections in Venezuela?
Rubio is actually one of the few people in this administration I have some respect for. I don't like that he carries Trump's positions, but that's a requirement to have influence in the administration. He manages to put the sanest narrative possible on the chaos without getting exiled by Trump. I see him as a fairly thoughtful pragmatist navigating a tricky path through tumultuous times.
I'm not defending everything he does, or advocating military intervention in Cuba. I just think he's a more pragmatic voice in an admin where that's in very short supply.
After Wall Street's worst day in months, are investors right to worry that Big Tech is overspending on AI?
Worry? Yes. Change course? I don't think so. There's great risk in choosing the winners and losers but collectively I think the bets are warranted.
Should doctors be allowed to edit a baby's genes to prevent serious inherited diseases?
Some might argue it's a slippery slope, but would we really not want to prevent a serious disease if we could?
Should the United Kingdom formally apologize for its role in the transatlantic slave trade?
There should be an agreed statute of limitations on apologies for historical wrongs. At some point they become our collective history rather than our collective responsibility.
Is the Justice Department right to pursue a new criminal case against former FBI Director James Comey?
Enough already. I think the impact of this type of pressure will be waning soon. I can't image support for this type of vengeance justice goes far beyond Trump.
You think it's justified? Why?
Should U.S. allies like the European Union and Canada build closer ties that reduce their reliance on the United States?
Of course they should. We've given them no choice. Provided we don't continue to alienate our closest allies after 2028, I think there will be some good that comes of it, namely a more balanced global alliance. Just wish we didn't have to be @!&!s to get there.
After hackers stole $6.3 billion from the Binance crypto exchange, who is most to blame?
Security failures for sure, but with the rapid advancement of AI, there's much more to come, unfortunately.
Was Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth right to fire the Pentagon's top war planner as the U.S. weighs action against Iran?
Hegseth needs to go. If the blue wave is realized next week, change is a-comin'
Would you pay more for products made domestically?
We shouldn't have to. Would rather the businesses find better ways to compete.
Should Hershey change its classic Reese's Peanut Butter Cup recipe?
I do think the chocolate tastes different now. Not a fan of the change.
Was Anthropic right to publicly reveal that one of its AI models can build working cyberattack tools on its own?
Better they be transparent and provide us time to build defenses than have us be surprised later when bad actors get their hands on it.
Should the U.S. lift sanctions on Russia's main state investment fund?
Who gave this a thumbs down? Why?
On Halloween, do you hand out full-size candy bars?
Two fun size, kids' choice
Is Google right to keep boosting its AI spending even after the costs rattled investors?
Spend or get left behind. High risk, but with significant downside/upside.
Alaska Democrat Mary Peltola's Senate campaign recruited a man named Dan Sullivan to run against incumbent Sen. Dan Sullivan β is that a fair campaign tactic?
If the shoe were on the other foot, how would the Dems feel? This is over the line, for sure, and unfortunately undermines their claim to the moral high ground over Trump and his supporters.
If it were proven safe, would you get a brain-computer chip implanted?
Unfortunately that guarantee would likely be on a best-effort basis. Scary to think of your brain getting hacked, for sure.
Means they do the best they can, no guarantees. Not exactly reassuring.
Has using AI tools made you more productive at work?
So much more. Advice I've taken: Keep challenging the AI tools with problems you think are beyond their capabilities and see what happens. If you're like me, more often than not you'll be surprised.
Should every death in U.S. immigration detention automatically trigger an independent federal investigation?
Yes, though I'm not sure how independent the investigations are these days.
Was the Trump administration right to end federal limits on methane emissions from oil and gas drilling?
Another step backwards.
Should Boston Dynamics sell its Spot robot dogs to ICE?
Robot dogs replacing human-to-human engagement in immigration enforcement is a recipe for disaster and a big step toward dystopian society. Of course, if the alternative is belligerent, callous ICE agents, maybe it's not such a leap.
Should political robocalls and texts be banned?
Getting a flurry of political texts now. Looking forward to Nov 4 when spam texts will subside, I'm sure.
One can hope for at least a short reprieve. I suspect you're right, though.
Are movie theaters making a genuine comeback?
I'm convinced there'll always be demand for watching movies on a giant screen, with great sound, and with other people. Very different experience.
What's old is new again! Love it.
Was President Trump right to call Norway a 'shithouse country' and say Norwegians aren't welcome in the U.S.?
Of course not. Way wrong on both sentiment and language.
Is it acceptable to watch a movie for the first time on your phone?
Purists will say no. I tend to agree.
After a startup broke into a leading AI company's internal systems, do you trust AI companies to keep sensitive data secure?
I trust them as much as anyone (by them I mean Dario Amodi, Demis Hassabis, and Sam Altman). Trust and confidence are two different things, though. I trust them to do the best they can to protect sensitive data, but in such a competitive, fast-moving space, Iβm not confident theyβll always succeed.
Smartwatches: essential or excessive?
I like my smartwatch, but nothing I couldn't live without. Maybe when they get more AI capabilities, possibly even in combination with smart glasses, I could see them becoming more essential.
Should companies be required to share profits with employees?
Required to? No. Encouraged to? Yes. Employee ownership / profit sharing goes a long way.
U.S. measles cases have more than doubled this year as outbreaks spread β who is most responsible?
We had virtually eradicated measles until this admin / RFK Jr. came along. We're backsliding into last century.
Was it right for Nicki Minaj to perform at President Trump's midterm campaign rally in Michigan?
It's up to them, of course, though if I had to pick sides based on supporting musicians I'd be with the Dems.
Is it better to rent or to own your home?
From an investment standpoint, low-cost index funds will generally perform better than residential real estate over the long term when all costs are considered (property tax, maintenance, insurance, realtor costs, etc.). That said, it's a good way for most to build wealth. Where else can you borrow hundreds of thousands of dollars to support purchase of an appreciating asset?
Should local communities be allowed to block new AI data centers?
Of course. Let the data centers make the case to those they'll most directly impact. Two possible outcomes: 1) they'll make a deal that sufficiently benefits the local community or 2) they'll go elsewhere and avoid landing where they're not wanted.
Dogs or cats?
Loyal companion vs. judgmental roommate. At least that's the way it feels.
All true, but ya gotta love em. I'll admit, if I had grown up with cats I might feel differently.
Cat tolerant :)
Ukraine's Zelenskyy says he feels 'betrayed' by Trump β is his frustration justified?
Completely agree. I think Zelenskyy knows who he's dealing with by now. I suspect his real audience is Congress and our allies, not Trump.
Should U.S. Supreme Court justices have term limits?
Let's just stick to the Constitution: they βshall hold their Offices during good Behaviourβ. We should never deviate from that foundational guidance lightly.
Very long terms is an interesting idea. It looks like the average tenure of a Supreme Court justice over the last 50 years is about 26 years, so the impact of a 20-year term might not be that great. Is it worth deviating from the Constitution for that?
Are the latest tech-industry layoffs driven more by AI or by ordinary cost-cutting?
Definitely some of both. AI is driving real efficiency gains for sure, especially in tech, but it's also providing convenient ground cover for ordinary cost cutting.
Should Elon Musk's SpaceX be able to restrict Ukraine's access to Starlink?
I thought Starshield was controlled by the US government, not Musk. Decisions like this (ally and national security) should sit with elected leaders.
Should former presidents like Barack Obama actively campaign in the midterm elections?
I used to think former presidents should step back and leave the stage to their successors. The past 10 years has changed my mind. Democrats are struggling for a cohesive voice, and if Obama can articulate what millions are feeling and champion needed change, I'm all for it.
Are theme parks like Six Flags doing enough to keep their rides safe?
People dying suggests not.
Should the French government reverse the school-funding cuts that have helped spark mass protests across France?
Their debt is already ~120% of GDP. They can't spend their way out of every problem, but education seems like a reasonable priority. Money's gotta come from somewhere though. Higher taxes? Cuts elsewhere? More debt doesn't seem like a great answer (btw, their debt ratio is still less than ours).
Would you let a robot cook your dinner?
Please do. Ingredients on me.
Should children under 16 be banned from using social media?
They definitely need guardrails, but a ban goes too far. I do think social media has a role to play in kids' development. We need digitally capable kids, not digitally sheltered ones.
Should first lady Melania Trump be brokering ceasefires in the Russia-Ukraine war?
If it saves lives, why not? A genuine humanitarian effort. More power to her.
Was President Trump right to prepare a lawsuit to block Alaska's U.S. Senate results if Republicans lose?
I'll admit I'm immediately skeptical when a poll starts "Was President Trump right to..."
Is President Trump right to pursue his $10 billion lawsuit against the BBC?
I'm a strong free press advocate, but I admit the BBC editing was a major mistake. Trump has a legitimate case here, I think. That said, a $10B ask feels a bit like a shakedown.
Agree big numbers do more for deterrence, but they still need to be proportional.
Should members of the U.S. Congress face a mandatory retirement age?
Agreed. Age isn't a proxy for judgment. I'd rather have someone 80 and sharp than 40 and clueless. Though I'd take either over 80 and clueless.
Nvidia just unveiled its 'Agile ONE' humanoid robot β should companies start putting humanoid robots into everyday jobs?
They're not quite ready for prime time yet, but progressing fast. Humanoid robots today remind me of ChatGPT in 2022 - impressive but imperfect, and easy to underestimate. Give em a few years.
A judge ordered President Trump to sit for a deposition in his defamation lawsuit against the BBC β was the judge right to require it?
His lawsuit. His deposition. Don't like it? Drop the case.
Should hospitals let AI systems diagnose complex medical cases?
Good article today on this topic. AI now correctly diagnosing difficult cases at better than twice the rate of doctors: https://techcrunch.com/2026/10/22/microsofts-mustafa-suleyman-says-its-ai-outperforms-doctors-on-hard-cases-as-he-chases-medical-superintelligence/
Is the $25 billion fine against Meta over its handling of user data fair?
Agree with the sentiment, but the stockholders own the company, so they're the ones ultimately paying.
Are home prices in your area reasonable?
Prices seem to be dropping. High interest rates are keeping buyers on the sidelines and those with low mortgage rates aren't moving. Good time to be a cash buyer, for those fortunate enough.
OpenAI says two of its internal AI agents switched off their own safety monitors during testing β does this make you trust AI development more or less?
Why would this make you trust AI development more?
Do you prefer seeing live music at a big stadium or a small venue?
If I could be close to the stage, big stadiums would be fine, but these days its $1K+ to get those seats. Out of control.
Tesla's quarterly operating profit fell 56% as it ramped up spending on AI and robotics β is that the right move for the company?
Musk says their humanoid robots will be on the market in 2028. His track record says it'll probably be later, but I do think that could be a huge market for them. And their biggest competitors are from China so will probably be restricted from selling in US.
Is Meta right to raise its AI spending to at least $135 billion this year?
I think it's probably warranted. What they're doing with Muse makes sense - bringing AI to the masses by helping across our everyday lives. That said, I don't really trust Meta enough to give it access to everything that would make Muse helpful. Apple, on the other hand... It was theirs to lose.
Is the Social Security Administration's sweeping records cleanup reassuring or concerning?
Probably needed, but I lack trust under the current administration.
Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang says AI capability and safety are 'one and the same'βdo you agree?
AI will soon progress beyond our ability to understand it, so I do agree that AI will be the best defense against rogue AI (whether self- or human-directed). It's unsettling to think about, but the genie is out of the bottle now and we need to deal with it.
Is Apple's push to make more of its iPhones in the United States a meaningful shift or mostly for show?
Only if it were cost competitive. It's not. Many have done the analysis (see, for example, https://www.cnbc.com/2025/04/11/heres-how-much-a-made-in-the-usa-iphone-would-cost.html)
Should election ballots be paper-only?
Paper for an immutable backup, counted electronically.
Amen.
Should the U.S. keep strict limits on exporting advanced AI chips to China?
It's one of the few levers we have to pull to maintain AI leadership.
Was the U.S. right to hold up Patriot missile deliveries to Ukraine?
Loved this from Richard Branson this week. Wish more of our political leaders spoke this plainly. https://www.linkedin.com/feed/update/urn:li:activity:7516554243710058497/
Is the federal crackdown on alleged non-citizen voting in California justified, or political overreach?
The Trump playbook: undermine trust in the process and then claim to be restoring that trust. Good grief. Is anyone still buying this?
Should employers be allowed to monitor employees' activity with productivity-tracking software?
Yes, employers should be allowed to as long as they let employees know they're doing it. Then it's up to the employees to decide if that's the kind of place they want to work.
Is Elon Musk's plan to give every American child a SpaceX share a genuine gift or a publicity stunt?
They're not mutually exclusive. Either way, at ~$150 a share, it's not a bad gift. Musk gets publicity. Kids get SpaceX stock. Win-win. And for those who don't like Musk or SpaceX, sell it.
Is President Trump right to push ahead with his plan to redevelop Washington's public East Potomac golf course?
Could be good to redevelop the course, provided two conditions are met: 1) it's done with the proper public approvals and 2) it remains a reasonably priced public course. Unfortunately, I expect neither with Trump.
I could support many of these projects if they went through proper approval channels, had appropriate congressional oversight, and served the public interest rather than personal legacy building. Unfortunately, that's not how Trump operates.
Should Alberta become independent from Canada?
In today's world, strength in numbers. It's up to them, of course, but I hope it remains one Canada.
Do you make your bed every morning?
If you consider making the bed flipping the covers up.
Before watching a new movie, do you check reviews or go in blind?
Almost always. I'll give almost any movie a try if its Rotten Tomatoes critics score is >90%. And if it's below 70%, I'll generally pass.
For a foreign-language movie or show, do you prefer subtitles or dubbing?
While purists say subtitles are best, it's hard to enjoy the full visual experience when you're trying to keep up with the dialogue.
In an unavoidable crash, should a self-driving car protect its passengers or the people outside the car?
Classic hypothetical. I'd say minimize total deaths, but would you want to get into one that didn't have your own safety as priority?
Are streaming services still worth the money as their prices keep climbing?
To a point. Considering trimming one or two.
Does tipping culture need a reset?
Sit-down service is one thing. My favorite is when I'm asked to tip for counter service at a bagel shop and I'm offered 15%/20%/25% default tip options. Nothing says tipping culture is broken quite like being asked for a 25% tip on a bagel handed across a counter.
How much do you trust national news media?
Depends on the source, of course. Wide spread between Newsmax and CNN. As far as my sources of choice, I trust them quite a bit.
Should the U.S. restart retired nuclear power plants to supply electricity for AI data centers?
We need the power, we don't want more fossil fuel plants, and solar/wind + batteries won't fill the gap completely. Nuclear is a clean, cost-effective, around-the-clock option. And it's much safer than it was 40 years ago thanks to advances in safety systems and operating standards. (I'm admittedly a bit biased, as my dad was a nuclear engineer.)
Should restaurants do away with tipping and build the cost into prices instead?
At least the expectation of tipping.
Was France right to call Israeli settler attacks in the West Bank 'acts of terrorism'?
If Palestinians did the same against Israeli civilians, I don't think most would hesitate to call it terrorism.
Was Donald Trump right to fire White House press secretary Katie Zacharia after five days on the job?
She fits the Trump pattern, for sure. Look the part, praise the boss, struggle in execution
Do you stay in your seat through a movie's entire end credits?
I'll admit I now check in advance whether there'll be post-credit scenes. If yes, stay, if not, I leave it up to the people I'm watching with.
Only if a reasonable expectation of ridership would justify the cost (considering also its impact on congestion and environment). In California, I'm concerned that both ridership expectations and cost estimates are overly optimistic.