J

JE_ThomasVoice #8

Member since September 2026

86 threads111 πŸ‘ received38 replies drawn
Tech & Science

Hacktivists published the identities of about 41,000 U.S. Homeland Security officials β€” can leaking government officials' identities ever be justified?

Identifying government employees shouldn't be problematic with the rare exceptions of those working as undercover agents for, say, the CIA. Doxing them is another thing altogether.

Nov 1πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Alaska Democrat Mary Peltola's Senate campaign recruited a man named Dan Sullivan to run against incumbent Sen. Dan Sullivan β€” is that a fair campaign tactic?

Legal but unethical. It shouldn't have been done. Republicans have a long history of dirty tricks. Roger Stone made an entire career out of dirty tricks. The solution is for American voters to eschew these antics but that requires a level of sophistication and engagement that has never existed here.

Nov 1πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Is President Trump right to question the legitimacy of Lula's election victory in Brazil?

Evidence matters. Casting doubt on elections is a hallmark of autocrats, Trump has complained for years that the 2020 election was stolen; laughable because he tried to steal it himself. There is ample evidence of Trump's attempt to steal the election, none that it was stolen from him. Having him question the loss of an election of a fellow autocrat wannabe in a foreign country with zero evidence is both predictabe and idiotic.

Nov 1πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Was the city of Cambridge right to divest its funds from businesses tied to Israel's military?

The city gets to invest where it chooses to invest. It doesn't matter whether their action changes anything on the ground or is purely symbolic.

Nov 1πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Should U.S. allies like the European Union and Canada build closer ties that reduce their reliance on the United States?

Nations need to pursue their national interests. Canada and Europe didn't walk away from the US, the US pushed them away. We are no longer a reliable partner in either commerce or defense. Our erstwhile allies should waste no time making other arrangements.

Nov 1πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Was the judge right to bar the Justice Department from pressuring election officials across the country before the midterms?

To those voting "No" I'd suggest they read the Constitution: "The Times, Places and Manner of holding Elections for Senators and Representatives, shall be prescribed in each State by the Legislature thereof; but the Congress may at any time by Law make or alter such Regulations, except as to the Places of chusing Senators." Article I, Section 4, Clause 1.

Nov 1πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Should the U.S. send its navy to protect oil tankers in the Strait of Hormuz?

Iran is a tar baby of our own creation. We need to be looking for an off ramp, not a way to become further involved in a forever war. The nations of the Middle East have the necessary tools and motivations to restore normal operations to the Strait of Hormuz and the Bab al-Mandab.

Nov 1πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Should the U.S. lift sanctions on Russia's main state investment fund?

Russia's leadership is a continuing threat to world peace. Until that changes the United States and every other nation committed to a stable world should keep maximum pressure on Russia.

Oct 29πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 12 repliesOpen thread β†’
Replying to dagman: β€œWho gave this a thumbs down? Why?”

Dunno, ,Dagman. Might have been Scaramouche, he seems to be a Russophile.

Oct 29πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Should the U.S. grant visas to Brazil's FlΓ‘vio Bolsonaro and his family after his election loss?

At this moment Flavio Bolsonaro is a fugitive under investigation for serious crimes in Brazil. The visa is a slap in the face of the rule of law.

Oct 29πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Was the Trump administration right to end federal limits on methane emissions from oil and gas drilling?

Are you kidding me? Methane is a much more potent driver of climate change than CO2. Ending emissions standards enables short term financial gains for a few producers at the cost of long term consequences for everyone.

Oct 29πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Was President Trump right to call Norway a 'shithouse country' and say Norwegians aren't welcome in the U.S.?

I think Trump will never get a Nobel Peace Prize for the simple reason that he doesn't deserve one. That makes the Nobel Committee ... noble, in my opinion. Attacking Norway and its people for a decision they don't control demonstrates how shockingly stupid our very stable genius actually is.

Oct 28πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Is Jair Bolsonaro right to refuse to concede Brazil's election?

Absent evidence it is meaningless, just like Trump's constant wailing about election fraud. What about charges that Trump molested underage chipmunks? See how easy that is? Whatabout, whatabout, whatabout. Evidence, please.

Oct 28πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Is the Justice Department right to pursue a new criminal case against former FBI Director James Comey?

It appears to be simple harassment.Throw one charge, then another, now a third trying to find something that might stick. It costs Trump nothing but Comey has to pay to defend himself each time. What's next, a charge that Comey picked his toenails in Hoboken? Enough already.

Oct 28πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Is Israel right to demolish Palestinian homes in the occupied West Bank after a deadly shooting there?

The deadly shootings in the Westbank are almost entirely of Palestinians. According to the UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA), at least 79 Palestinians (including 19 children) had been killed by Israeli forces or settlers in the West Bank as of late August 2026. As far as I can find, zero Israelis have. Now what was the question?

Oct 27πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Was a federal appeals court right to rule that President Trump exceeded his authority by federalizing California's National Guard?

Unless and until a higher court says otherwise, it is a fact of law that he exceeded his authority.

Oct 27πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 01 replyOpen thread β†’
News & Politics

Should political robocalls and texts be banned?

You can block robot-calls from commercial interests but not from political candidates? Why not? I get gimme requests from candidates as far away as Texas, Maine, and Ohio. I don't live in those states. Block 'em!

Oct 27πŸ‘ 3πŸ‘Ž 0Best receivedOpen thread β†’
News & Politics

Is Luiz InΓ‘cio Lula da Silva's reelection a good outcome for Brazil?

Instead of another Bolsinaro, a right-wing proto-autocrat just like his father? Yeah, a good thing for Brazil, a great thing.

Oct 27πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Tech & Science

U.S. measles cases have more than doubled this year as outbreaks spread β€” who is most responsible?

Vaccination is the single most important medical intervention ever devised. Life expectancy in this country was about 50 years a century ago, mostly because so many children died before the age of 15 from communicable diseases. Smallpox once killed millions. Polio, rubella (watch a video of an unvaccinated child with rubella some time), and yes, measles. I don't have the figures at hand but something like 1 in 20 children who contract measles will require hospitalization, 1 in 1,000 will die even with the best care medicine can offer, usually of encephalitis. Measles is no joke. There is all sorts of crap information circulating but this is you child's life. Be a responsible parent, learn the real facts, and get your kids vaccinated.

Oct 27πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Entertainment

Was it right for Nicki Minaj to perform at President Trump's midterm campaign rally in Michigan?

Sure. Minaj or anyone else is free to support the candidates of their choice. But people in the entertainment industry are generally smarter not to attach to political figures, especially those who are especially divisive. I am not alone in voting with my wallet. I no longer buy from Amazon as an example. It's the same with artists. The chance of me going to a Minaj or Kid Rock concert, never high before, are zero today.

Oct 27πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Business & Money

Is it better to rent or to own your home?

It depends on a great number of circumstances, some personal, some federal monetary policy. I have a mortgage at about 3%. Given the inflation rate I am borrowing that money for free, even being paid a little to borrow it. I could pay the loan off today but why would I? Owning also allows me to do things that a rental would not. I have a substantial garden and a large shop in my backyard, neither common in rental situations. Rental makes sense for people who are likely to change jobs or move as their job demands change, for those who struggle to accumulate the down payment on a home, or for those who don't want to be bothered with maintenance costs and activities.

Oct 27πŸ‘ 2πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Should photo ID be required to vote in U.S. elections?

The problem isn't showing a photo ID when voting, in many places one can get, for instance, a driver's license without being a citizen. The issue is proving citizenship when registering to vote. When voting signatures are compared with the signature filed at the time of registration. The signature works on checks drafted on your account, on legal contracts, and throughout commerce and law. It works when voting in person and it works when voting by mail.

Oct 27πŸ‘ 2πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Should U.S. Supreme Court justices have term limits?

The Supreme Court is the branch furthest from the people, in fact it has no connection to the people whatsoever. The Supreme Court system should be completely revamped by Constitutional amendment including term limits and a direct and clean path to remove sitting justices. This is supposed to be a government "of, by, and for the people."

Oct 20πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 01 replyOpen thread β†’
News & Politics

Was President Trump right to endorse Benjamin Netanyahu for reelection?

Birds of a feather flock together. And yeah, that includes vultures.

Oct 20πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 11 replyOpen thread β†’
News & Politics

Should election ballots be paper-only?

This is a tiresome issue. Voter fraud has been investigated ad nauseum and demonstrated NOT TO BE A PROBLEM. But who cares about evidence right? All you need is some clown with an IQ of 65 saying, "but,, but, but..." We have real, serious problems in this country, So let's spend a bunch of time relitigating election fraud for the umpteenth time.

Oct 20πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 12 repliesOpen thread β†’
Tech & Science

If it were proven safe, would you get a brain implant that lets you control devices with your thoughts?

Plug me into the matrix. I'll lay on a Barcalounger and think, "bring me a mezze plate and a glass of wine." (rolls eyes)

Oct 20πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

In the standoff over California's voter rolls, who is more in the right β€” the Trump administration or California?

This is't even a question. Read the frigging Constitution. "The Times, Places and Manner of holding Elections for Senators and Representatives, shall be prescribed in each State by the Legislature thereof; but the Congress may at any time by Law make or alter such Regulations, except as to the Places of chusing Senators." - Article I, Section 4, Clause 1.

Oct 20πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

How much do you trust national news media?

I read news from a wide variety of sources but very little opinion from any source.

Oct 19πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Tech & Science

Should the U.S. restart retired nuclear power plants to supply electricity for AI data centers?

That depends entirely on the condition of the plants and the plans to handle the waste. I have long been a proponent of nuclear energy but it must be exploited carefully,

Oct 19πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Who is most responsible for the rise in threats against U.S. politicians?

It is no longer possible to simply disagree. Today, those with whom you disagree are framed as subhuman. The trend has been growing since the Clinton administration but you can thank the orange idiot and his wannabee storm troopers for raising it to truly frightening levels. This is the First Amendment turned to self-parody, Rights are sacrosanct but with every right comes a concomitant responsibility,

Oct 19πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 11 replyOpen thread β†’
News & Politics

How should France's government respond to the violent nationwide protests over the cost of living?

Order must be restored. To protest is one thing, to riot and destroy property is quite another. Macron has been slow to react to growing discontent and that's on him. But some of the protesters' demands are unrealistic too. Tough spot for Macron.

Oct 19πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 11 replyOpen thread β†’
News & Politics

Is President Trump right to push ahead with his plan to redevelop Washington's public East Potomac golf course?

Trup has vandalized Washington, DC by whim, destroying the East Wing of the White House, destroying the Rose Garden for a helipad, and trying to build an arch to himself. Enough.

Oct 19πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 01 replyOpen thread β†’
News & Politics

Should news outlets be required to disclose their funding sources?

Yes. Transparency matters. If it was up to me even votes would be public.

Oct 18πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Should U.S. cities be allowed to adopt 'sanctuary' policies that limit their cooperation with federal immigration agents?

Different layers of government should be responsive to their citizens. The feds have massive resources of their own. They can also petition courts to compel certain actions.

Oct 18πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Do large nationwide protests like the 'No Kings' marches actually change government policy?

Not policy usually, but they focus voters on the issue

Oct 18πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 11 replyOpen thread β†’
Business & Money

Should taxpayers help cover AI companies' legal costs when their technology causes serious harm?

Are taxpayers going to be paid dividends?

Oct 18πŸ‘ 2πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Tech & Science

Should powerful AI models like China's new DeepSeek be released as free, open-source software anyone can download?

Nothing is free. Sometimes the price is hidden.

Oct 18πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Japan's PM Sanae Takaichi says housework and makeup add hours to her workday β€” do comments like that point to a real problem for working women?

If someone is doing all of the housework they need a housekeeper or a divorce.

Oct 18πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Just for Fun

Does ketchup belong on a hot dog?

Replying to Scaramouche: β€œI have a Chicagoan friend; when I E-mailed him after Pope Leo's election, he told me they were hoping for a Papal edict formally condemning …”

A mortal sin!

Oct 17πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Business & Money

After this week's global stock market selloff, are fears about AI companies' profits justified?

Sizzle is great but ROI is what it's all about.

Oct 17πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Was the European Union right to postpone its summit with Gulf nations after a Houthi missile strike on Yemen's presidential palace?

Postponing the summit us a Houthi win. Just don't

Oct 17πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Was President Trump right to rule out sending U.S. ground troops into Iran?

Boots on the ground? Yeah, let's take a terrible situation and make it much, much worse.

Oct 17πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Tech & Science

What's stopping you from an EV?

My next car will be an EV - but not a Tesla.

Oct 17πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

With the 2026 U.S. midterms weeks away, should Election Day be a national holiday?

Anything that makes it easier to vote!

Oct 17πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

As the U.S. weighs new strikes on Iran, should a president announce in advance which military options he won't use?

The Iran war is an unnecessary stupidity. Nonetheless, surprise is an essential element of warfare.

Oct 17πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 1Open thread β†’
Entertainment

Animated films: just for kids?

Futurama. South Park. The Simpsons.

Oct 17πŸ‘ 2πŸ‘Ž 01 replyOpen thread β†’
Tech & Science

Is AI company Anthropic worth its roughly $1.5 trillion IPO valuation?

No, and I like Anthropic. It's over valued and investors are betting on the come.

Oct 17πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Business & Money

With U.S.–Mexico trade talks stalled, should the U.S. keep its tariffs on Mexican goods?

They were stupid to begin with and they aren't getting better with age.

Oct 17πŸ‘ 2πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

After an armed parent killed the attacker in the Bend, Oregon elementary school shooting, are armed citizens an effective way to stop school shootings?

I'm glad it worked out the way it did but it isn't the answer to mass murder.

Oct 17πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Was Donald Trump right to put the new Russia sanctions on hold just before they took effect?

Trump fellates Putin. Again. Knee pads and chapstick - making America great again.

Oct 17πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 1Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Was Donald Trump right to fire White House press secretary Katie Zacharia after five days on the job?

She was a train wreck, but oddly appropriate, no?

Oct 17πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 01 replyOpen thread β†’
News & Politics

Is it a problem that Elon Musk has spent about $276 million on the 2026 U.S. midterm elections?

I think America gets sold to the highest bidder since Citizens United. It is disgusting.

Oct 14πŸ‘ 2πŸ‘Ž 02 repliesOpen thread β†’
Replying to Scaramouche: β€œIt was true before; now it's just...tru-ER, I suppose. The main difference I notice is that I haven't heard the term "campaign finance refor…”

No, the Roberts Court killed that possibility. You won't hear it until they age out, the Court is expanded, or unexpected stones grow in Congress and they impeach them.

Oct 16πŸ‘ 2πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Was the federal search of Rep. Ilhan Omar's home justified?

I always favor letting investigations play out. But if this was done as an act of political intimidation - which it certainly appears to have been - there should be serious legal consequences for those involved.

Oct 15πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Tech & Science

Should SpaceX be allowed to restrict Ukraine's access to Starlink during its military operations?

It is StarShield, not StarLink that is the primary problem. A different problem is having private companies involved in international military affairs.

Oct 15πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Should the U.S. resume military strikes against Iran?

The US and other leading countries had a nuclear deal with Iran, the JCPOA, that was working very well indeed until Trump unilaterally abrogated it during his first administration. The United States was in active negotiations with Iran when Trump and Netanyahu launched an unprovoked attack and now an ongoing war. There shouldn't have been military force used then and there certainly shouldn't be military force used now. The forces roiling the Middle East go much, much deeper than Iran's theocratic government and those forces are more likely to be exacerbated than calmed by more military action in that troubled region.

Oct 15πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Business & Money

Does tipping culture need a reset?

I'm headed for Europe in the morning where tipping is as it should be. Tips are not expected (except in some tourist traps. Don't.). Typically, one might leave change or, in the case of exceptional service, a few Euros, kroner, or zloty. Waitstaff are typically professional and it is often seen as a career rather than something to do while going to school or waiting for something better.

Oct 13πŸ‘ 2πŸ‘Ž 06 repliesOpen thread β†’
Replying to Scaramouche: β€œLucky you; would you object to being more specific? Oh, BTW, if you didn't already know: THE NEW BIOMETRICS CRAP AT OUR AIRPORTS IS OPTIONAL…”

Flying in and out of FCO but spending time in Czech and Poland. I'm OK with the biometrics. I'm a US Global Entry holder so the government has pix, prints, and probably the results of my last colonoscopy.

Oct 13πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 1Open thread β†’
Replying to Scaramouche: β€œYou're familiar with the "boiling frog" effect, right? George Carlin's pre-TSA rant about airport-security has only gotten more potent with …”

But I'm not French!!!

Oct 14πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Replying to dagman: β€œHave a good trip, and safe travels!”

Thanks!

Oct 14πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Should there be a universal background check for all gun sales?

Replying to rovr322: β€œI’ve never met a gun owner who had a problem with a background check…..the problems arise from these β€œchecks” taking days or weeks and the i…”

Homicide rate in the US varies between 5.0 and 6.3 per 100,000 people. In the UK is is almost 5 times lower - 1.2 per 100,000.

Oct 13πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Replying to Scaramouche: β€œThe UK has fewer gun-crimes, but violent crimes with OTHER lethal weapons (e.g. knives, bludgeons, and acid) have gone up to compensate; it …”

See my response to rovr322 above. The figures don't hold. Murders, violent crime, total crime, even stabbings, the UK does much better than the US.

Oct 13πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Replying to rovr322: β€œHi JE_T, thanks for replying. I looked at 2024 statistics and got 1.0 for UK and 5.1 for US so we’re in agreement. But I ask you, if guns …”

I think the problem with guns is that it's too easy. Pull, point, squeeze. You don't even have to be all that close. And of course I don't know but I suspect for many the regret comes as quickly as the action.

Oct 14πŸ‘ 2πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Should the U.S. lift some sanctions on Iran to reopen the Strait of Hormuz?

Replying to Scaramouche: β€œ"I was referring to the CIA led overtheow [sic] of an elected PM and replacing him with the Shah." I am confused; you made it sound like you…”

Scaramouche, I referred to the CIA overthrow of Mosaddegh as a bad thing, a terrible thing. If that didn't come across, I'm losing my touch. CIA overthrew Mosaddegh because he was planning to nationalize the oil fields that the UK had been milking like its own personal cow. That led to the Shah, and then to the CIA-trained SAVAK secret police. It's no damned wonder the Iranians hate the US.

Oct 13πŸ‘ 2πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Was Cornell University right to ban all fraternity parties?

Replying to Scaramouche: β€œBetter idea: Abolish the stupid Greek houses, let individuals form parties as they wish.”

I went to a college with no Greek life and figure myself better for the absence. A bunch of kids, most too you to legally drink, getting shit-face drunk and trying to get laid.

Oct 13πŸ‘ 2πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Should the U.S. return to the Moon before going to Mars?

Walk before you run. The trip to mars is 7+ MONTHS using current technology. Even a minor oopsie won't be fixed by the cavalry riding to the rescue. I'm not even sure sending humans to Mars makes sense. It has a really inhospitable climate, average temperature is about 85 below zero, there is no atmosphere to speak of, and most of the water is in the polar ice caps. Terrible place to live. Terrible place to die.

Oct 13πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Tech & Science

Would you put Apple's new HomeView smart-home display in your home?

I don't even know what it is, I watch little TV of the regular kind, and I imagine it's seriously overpriced. So, NO.

Oct 13πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Business & Money

Are companies pouring too much money into AI?

I don't know and neither does anyone else. It is a shit ton of money and sooner or later investors are going to want to see returns on the investment. That's when bubbles burst. The strongest and least leveraged will survive. Right now AI investment is keeping this country out of a recession so ... it's all good for now.

Oct 13πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Tech & Science

Do you agree with Sam Altman that the world should accept 'some bad things happening' to gain AI's benefits?

No. Sam Altman should accept "some bad things happening" and that he and his investors will have to pay for the damages. That's how liability works. If my 10 year old hits a baseball through your living room window, I don't get to say, well, "some bad things are going to happen."

Oct 13πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Should Kimberly Guilfoyle have resigned as U.S. ambassador to Greece?

She should have been fired. From a circus cannon. Into a vat of something stinky and vile. She was an embarrassment to the nation.

Oct 13πŸ‘ 3πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Business & Money

Are open-plan offices good for work?

There is no "correct" answer to this question. It depends entirely on the work.

Oct 12πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 02 repliesOpen thread β†’
Replying to Scaramouche: β€œThe way people talk about "The Workplaceβ„’" as though they're all the same is irritating at minimum, and even downright creepy.”

To say nothing of self-defeating. But you know American businessmen usually like to do whatever the consultants say so this year it's open floor plans, next year it will be team calisthenics. But at least there aren't mandated testosterone injections like the military. Jesus, you can't make this shit up.

Oct 13πŸ‘ 2πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Should U.S. presidential pardons require approval from an independent review panel?

The pardon power has been abused and exploited both parties for decades. It will require a Constitutional Amendment to curtail that power but it is none-the-less worth pursuing.

Oct 12πŸ‘ 2πŸ‘Ž 03 repliesOpen thread β†’
Replying to Scaramouche: β€œReplacing it with a 'popular pardon' might be nice.”

Yeah ... not sure how that would work in a nation of 350 million.

Oct 13πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Business & Money

Is the Justice Department right to open an antitrust investigation into major TV networks?

Not unless they're going to open antitrust investigations into both major political parties.

Oct 12πŸ‘ 2πŸ‘Ž 02 repliesOpen thread β†’
Replying to Scaramouche: β€œI'm not sure why not doing that would sour this, but hell yeah, that'd be a great idea!”

The antitrust investigation of networks is the Trump administration's retribution for the networks shunning him after he banished CNN and a few others from the White House. This isn't about business practices, it's about making them knuckle under t a wannabe dictator.

Oct 13πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Should the U.S. join Saudi Arabia's military campaign against the Houthis?

Does anyone seriously think that embroiling ourselves in another Middle East war is a good idea? Saudi Arabia has a quarter of a million men under arms and a Texas shitload of American weaponry including more than 350 aircraft and 575 Abrams tanks. Saudi Arabia also has an assist from Pakistan and presumably can entice Turkey to help. Not our circus. Not our monkeys. It's time we learned that lesson.

Oct 12πŸ‘ 2πŸ‘Ž 04 repliesOpen thread β†’
Replying to Scaramouche: β€œWell, sort of "our monkeys", if I understand the idiom, but the solution is to stop sustaining them, so your thrust is right either way.”

The idiom means, more or less, that I or we are not responsible for the enterprise, whatever that may be, nor for the individuals involved. In this case the US has no treaty obligation to SA (though there may be an implied obligation) and we have no control over the Saudis of the Houthis.

Oct 13πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Entertainment

When a book is being made into a movie, do you read the book first or watch the movie first?

I read the book. Period. I haven't been to a movie in years. I'm not aware of a film worth my time.

Oct 13πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 02 repliesOpen thread β†’
Replying to Scaramouche: β€œRecent worthwhile movies that come to my mind: "Oppenheimer" was AMAZING (and I went in with pessimistic expectations). Did you like "Beetle…”

I read the biography. I may stream the movie at some point. I loved Beetlejuice. In fact I went to a Halloween party as Beetlejuice a couple of years ago. The full monte. People, even relatives, didn't recognize me. If I stumble across the sequel I'll give it a look.

Oct 13πŸ‘ 2πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Social Security's 2027 cost-of-living raise was just announced β€” is it big enough?

As usual, surveys want answers lacking nuance. The 2.8% COLA is fine, even generous, for those of us with significant resources, not nearly enough for those for whom Social Security was originally intended.

Oct 13πŸ‘ 2πŸ‘Ž 02 repliesOpen thread β†’
Replying to Scaramouche: β€œIf COLA isn't pegged to inflation, it damned well should be.”

It is pegged to inflation. It's just that people who didn't earn much didn't contribute much and don't get much in the way of benefits. The average SS benefit in the US is $2,087.52 as of August according to the SSA. I don't think that people can live on that.

Oct 13πŸ‘ 2πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Heading into the 2026 midterms, is Mike Johnson the right person to lead House Republicans?

Has there ever been a less competent House Speaker? Johnson's only qualification is his complete subservience to Donald J. Trump. If the man has ever had a thought of his own, he's kept it to himself. The GOP members in the House may reconsider keeping him in leadership depending on the results of the election. If it is as bad as predicted and if I were an incumbent who managed to squeak through to reelection, I'd be looking to the future and how the trajectory might be changed. Mike Johnson is not the answer.

Oct 13πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 02 repliesOpen thread β†’
Replying to Scaramouche: β€œI don't know about "competent", but he couldn't possibly be more malevolent than Tom DeLay.”

Malevolence runs in the GOP bloodstream. I take that as a given, like French girls are going to have hairy armpits.

Oct 13πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 1Open thread β†’
Business & Money

Would you move states for a lower cost of living?

I live where I live, the Pacific Northwest, for quality of life. If I was younger I'd move to Copenhagen for the same reason.

Oct 13πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Tech & Science

Does leaning on AI tools for schoolwork weaken students' ability to think for themselves?

Did calculators weaken students' ability to do arithmetic? Why yes they did. But not in ways that made much difference. I find it amusing when clerks can't make change in their heads, but it hasn't resulted in a crisis of civilization. AI is different. It is a wonderful aid in producing better work. I use it often for research and proofreading. It is a debilitating crutch when used to do the work for you.

Oct 13πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 1Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Is the Justice Department right to investigate sitting members of Congress in the weeks before the 2026 midterm elections?

DOJ has avoided investigative splashes involving politicians in the weeks before an election. There is nothing to say that investigators couldn't work quietly behind the scenes, gathering evidence and building a timeline. But a high profile raid in the run up to an election looks like abuse of power. It will be interesting to see if there is actual evidence of criminal activity or if, as in the case of Lisa Cook (a Federal Reserve Board member Trump tried to fire) it is some insignificant paperwork error.

Oct 13πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Just for Fun

Pumpkin pie or apple pie?

Any pie. I'm not a cake guy.

Oct 12πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Should the U.S. keep pushing for a Russia-Ukraine energy ceasefire after Russia kept bombing Ukrainian gas sites?

No. Russia is the aggressor here. full stop. The United States should GIVE Ukraine as many interceptors as we can spare (likely 11 after the idiocy in Iran) and sell them whatever non-nuclear weapons they choose to buy (or the EU is willing to buy on their behalf).

Oct 12πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Business & Money

Should companies be allowed to require employees to sign non-compete agreements?

Yes, but only in extremely limited circumstances. There are already abundant laws to protect intellectual property.

Oct 12πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Entertainment

Should TV shows keep full opening theme songs, or cut straight to the episode?

(rolls eyes, walks away)

Oct 12πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 1Open thread β†’
Tech & Science

Should parents be allowed to genetically choose non-medical traits like height or eye color for their babies?

Eye color is pretty straightforward but many other traits are formed by the interplay of multiple genes. The possibility of unintended consequences suggests caution. but people ae going to do what they're going to do. All of the world's problems, all of the opportunities to better the arc of mankind, and people want to make sure that their daughter is blond. Eff me in the eye with a fork.

Oct 12πŸ‘ 2πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Entertainment

Can comedy go too far?

Go too far according to what measure? Art should sometimes confront, disturb, enrage. The best art forces one to examine their biases and preconceptions. If you can't handle that, don't watch.

Oct 12πŸ‘ 2πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Is the Saudi-led coalition right to promise a 'firm' military response to the Houthi attack on Riyadh's airport?

Iran isn't going away despite Trump's periodic vows to destroy it as a civilization. The Sunni powers in the ME need to come to some diplomatic detente with the Shia powers, Iran being foremost among the latter. Foreign powers including the US aren't going to settle that. And the underlying irritants of Israel and the plight of the Palestinians isn't going to be solved by foreign powers either, though there is a role available as an honest broker. The US though has probably destroyed its ability to fill that role. Today, the US and its military bases scattered across the region are a destabilizing rather than a stabilizing force. We - and the Arab countries - need to confront those realities.

Oct 12πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

After the deadly family shooting in Pennsylvania, what would do the most to prevent mass shootings?

Stricter gun laws, better mental health services, and a Constitutional Amendment striking the Second Amendment and replacing it with something far more restrictive.

Oct 12πŸ‘ 2πŸ‘Ž 3Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Was President Trump right to criticize Ukraine's strikes on Russian oil refineries?

Russia attacked Ukraine. Whether declared by Russia or not, that is an act of war. Ukraine has shown considerable restraint while russia has actively attacked purely civilian targets. Ukraine has every right to attack military and economic targets.

Oct 12πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 1Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Should former U.S. presidents be allowed to keep their security clearances after leaving office?

Security clearances are periodically reviewed. Presidents should be no different.

Oct 12πŸ‘ 2πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Should most working-age adults be required to work, volunteer, or study to keep their Medicaid coverage?

The devil is in the "most" in the question. Writing uniform rules that cover all of the reasonable exclusions of a work requirement is all but impossible. Denying routine medical care to anyone is morally wrong and economically stupid.

Oct 11πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Should the U.S. Justice Department be allowed to collect states' voter-roll data before the 2026 midterms?

Read the frigging Constitution. Article I, Section 4, "The Times, Places and Manner of holding Elections for Senators and Representatives, shall be prescribed in each State by the Legislature thereof; but the Congress may at any time by Law make or alter such Regulations, except as to the Places of chusing Senators." While Congress may diddle with this the Executive branch cannot.

Oct 11πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Tech & Science

Anonymous accounts: essential or toxic?

While the history of anonymous commentary is long in this nation, I fail to see its value. If one advocates a position, why wouldn't one be willing to put their name on it? The withholding of that is by its very nature deceitful. I want to know who pays for political ads, who advocates for this or that position, who attempts to shape public discourse. As bots and fakery become ubiquitous this information becomes ever more important.

Oct 11πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’

Founding Voices β†’

JE_Thomas β€” Groundbeat